Employer Branding
Recruitment
Three steps to a successful interview (and the most common pitfalls)
01 SEPTEMBER 2022
Do you conduct job interviews without really having much experience? You are not alone. The interview is a critical part of the decision to hire a new colleague and usually one of the biggest challenges in a recruitment process. All the more reason to level up your interview technique and feel more confident in the role.
Our Talent Managers at Oddwork conduct over 1,000 interviews a year, so they know what a difference well-prepared, high-quality interviews make.
The impact of good interviews
👉 The candidate gets a positive experience of the company and will probably share that feeling with everyone they talk to (never underestimate word of mouth)
👉 You get the best possible conditions for making a well-founded decision you can feel confident about
👉 Bad hires are expensive. By putting a little extra effort into your interview technique, you can avoid them to a greater extent.
Here is the winning interview structure used by Oddwork’s Talent Managers: three clear steps with tips + common pitfalls (and how to avoid them). Let’s go!
Looking for your next job? See open positions via Oddwork or read what recruiters look for.
“As a recruiter I want to match the right person with the right role, not pick the one who sells themselves best. It is my job to break down the barriers and get to know the person well enough that I can make that call.”— Madeleine Linge, Senior Talent Manager at Oddwork
First conversation: phone interview
Once you have selected interesting candidates based on their CV and cover letter, it is time for the first conversation, where you can quickly check the person and their interest in the role.
Keep in mind:
✅ Short and sweet
It should be a short and concise call, 15 to 30 minutes at most.
✅ Book a time in advance
Schedule the call with the candidate so they can talk from a suitable place.
✅ Write down your questions
Prepare a set of questions you want answered.
Common pitfalls:
🚨You forget to check the hard facts
Dare to talk salary already at this stage! Take the chance to check hard facts such as salary expectations, notice period and other requirements (for example a driving licence or languages). That way both you and the candidate know whether it is worth continuing the process, which simply respects everyone’s valuable time.
First meeting: face-to-face interview
The phone interview went well and both you and the candidate want to move on to the next step. It is time to meet for the first time, digitally or in person. The main purpose is for you to get a clear picture of the person’s ambitions, skills and goals, but also see it as an opportunity to present yourselves as an attractive employer.
Keep in mind:
✅ Leave room for questions
Give the person in front of you space to ask questions back. Think of it more as a dialogue than an interrogation.
✅ Sell the company
This is your chance to present the company as an attractive employer. Don’t take it for granted that the person wants to work for you; it is a candidates’ market.
✅ Keep it balanced
One or at most two people from your side is about right. More than that tips the balance and the candidate may feel pressured. Imagine sitting in front of five people versus one.
Common pitfalls
🚨You fire off too many questions.
You want to ask far too much at once, so the person feels bombarded with questions rather than excited about the job.
🚨Talking too much about private life.
Focus on competence. Many make the mistake of getting too personal: questions like “do you have children” or “do you have a girlfriend” can be sensitive (the person may not be able to have children, or the man in front of you may be married to a man). A suitably personal question could be what the person does in their spare time, which lets them choose what to share.
Second meeting: getting closer
Both sides are interested, so now you can get even more concrete. This is a good time to focus more on hard facts such as skills and tasks, perhaps with a work sample.
Keep in mind:
✅ Focus on the tasks
Go into more detail about the work: what does a normal day actually look like?
✅ Match values
Check the candidate’s values and match them with the company’s. Do they align?
✅ Meet the team
It is important for the candidate to get a feel for their closest colleagues, to get an idea of what everyday life would be like.
✅ Map skills
What can you do and what can’t you do? Mapping skills gives a much better overview and makes it possible to plan a relevant onboarding.
Common pitfalls:
🚨Not talking about expectations
It is important to be clear about the expectations that come with the role, and for the candidate to share theirs. The fewer surprises, the better.
🚨You oversell the role
Be transparent and open about the challenges that exist and lie ahead. That gives the candidate a better chance of taking on the role with the right expectations.
Download Oddwork’s recruitment guide
Concrete steps for running a recruitment process that succeeds from more perspectives than just the end goal. We help you recruit like a pro.